Maison Margiela Replica Beach Walk vs Tom Ford Soleil Blanc

3 Reddit comments name these two together with a dupe, clone or "smells like" phrase (2 from people who say they own or wore one of them). Maison Margiela is a designer house; Tom Ford is a luxury house.

Limited evidence: fewer than 5 comments make this comparison.

Maison Margiela Replica Beach Walk

Citrus & Fresh · 25 owner comments
3.1
No buy link.We could not find this fragrance sold by Amazon.com or by the brand’s own Amazon store, so we do not link to it.We only link Amazon listings sold by Amazon.com itself or by the brand’s own Amazon store, because fragrance on Amazon carries a real counterfeit and grey-market risk. Why we do this →

Tom Ford Soleil Blanc

Floral · 27 owner comments
2.8
No buy link.We could not find this fragrance sold by Amazon.com or by the brand’s own Amazon store, so we do not link to it.We only link Amazon listings sold by Amazon.com itself or by the brand’s own Amazon store, because fragrance on Amazon carries a real counterfeit and grey-market risk. Why we do this →

What the comments say

Not rated (no clear sentiment)

“Valaya , Valaya Exclusif, Meliora, Cassili,Missing Person, Dama Bianca, Love-O-Matic, Wulong Cha, Clean Warm Cotton, La Mar, El Sireno, Rosario, Agua de Santos, Bal d'Afrique, Blanche, La Tulipe, Philosykos, Fleur de Peau, L'eau Papier, Carnal Flower, Métalliq”

owner comment via r/FemFragLab · 2026-07-03 · 5 upvotes
Not rated (no clear sentiment)

“A coconut fragrance that doesn't smell like sunscreen, to me all of the heavy hitters smell like coppertone, ive tried so many, soleil blanc, beach walk, Alien, Vanilla Vibes, Maldives in a bottle, sunkissed goddess, all sunscreen to me”

owner comment via r/fragrance · 2026-05-05 · 2 upvotes
Not rated (no clear sentiment)

“That's what I was hoping for out of Soleil Blanc but it was feminine and too similar to Beach Walk.”

comment via r/Colognes · 2026-08-03 · 1 upvotes

Scores side by side

Replica Beach WalkSoleil Blanc
Overall score3.12.8
Owner sentiment4.03.6
Longevity3.7Not rated
Projection2.92.5
Compliments2.3Not rated

Each score comes from that fragrance's own owner comments. Read both reviews: Maison Margiela Replica Beach Walk · Tom Ford Soleil Blanc. More pairings on the dupes hub.